Thinking about the portrayal of slavery in text and in film

Part 1: Based on what I have read and what I heard from other researchers, I would characterize evidence from the collection of historic teachings on the portrayal of slavery and enslaved people as carefully factual and usually very romanticized. Often the authors remained with their facts rather than picking a side, and truly didn't delve too deeply into the darker depths or wrongness of slavery, after all in its time it had been accepted. 
The ideas and assumptions taught to students of the different ages showed how for the young it wasn't very mentioned, rather it only gave stories to try and begin teaching morals before slowly beginning to give more information of the time, teaching the younger ones on how to properly behave and begin to think in their time period. This might have impacted experience in and out of a classroom by giving students a way to interpret how the world was supposed to be seen, the norms to apply to daily life and how things should be, in a way inside the classroom was molding for the students on how they should be outside the classroom.

Part 2:
In class, we read an excerpt from the book, The Half Has Never Been Told
 (Links to an external site.).  Compare and Contrast the discussion of enslaved labor that was presented in that book, with the depiction of enslaved labor presented in the historic teaching books we examined in class.  Be sure to consider the extent to which authors offered evidence-based arguments.

Part 3: 
As an 11th-grade class, you watched the film, 12 Years a Slave, which brought to life the primary source written by Solomon Northrup, the  main character portrayed in the film.  
How would you summarize the film for someone who has never seen it? (3 sentences)
What did you see as the film's most powerful moment, and why?  (3 sentences)
What is the value of seeing a primary source like 12 Years a Slave brought to life?  What can you learn from watching a movie that you might not learn as readily from reading the 19th-century text version of the same events?  Would your recommend the experience for other students?  Why or why not?

Comments

  1. Ann LawsonOctober 29, 2019 at 4:29 AM

    Thanks for thinking about some of these questions. If you decide to complete the assignment, I'd be interesting in reading your thoughts on the other questions.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Confederacy Ideas Study

Image
There is a difference between Battle Flag and the simple confederate flag, often confused. I learned from analyzing what leaders of the Confederacy said about reasons for seceding the United States was  the Southern states ' desire to preserve the institution of slavery, to keep their true principle of what they thought was the truth For the battle flag of the Confederacy, I used to think of it standing in general as just something people united under sharing similar ideals, though having grown up in Arizona, white supremacy or southern pride wasn't present in my life until later... I now realize it, in fact, stands for the men who lost their lives fighting for a cause, later branching off into much different supposed ideals. I think it is more than possible to separate the battle flag from the stated goals of others using a similar or same version of the flag design as they stood for less overall ideals and more personal ones of the time that distracted the flag's
Read more

Party Guest List (Historical/Hidden Figures Version)

Image
Guest List/invites: 1.) Katherine Johnson. I would invite this woman out of pure respect and awe. I believe someone who has the bravery to stand up for what is right would be an excellent friend to have and would doubtlessly provide sense to a crazy party if it were needed. 2.) Taraji P. Henson. I would certainly invite this young woman. She seems as if she is a very down to Earth and adaptable type of person, I feel like she would help get a few laughs out of people and overall be a rather relatable friend. 3.) Mary Jackson. I feel like this would be our little beauty and queen of dance. She'd likely be the one making sure the games and decorations were just right and still would show up and outshine the rest, leading everyone into a great time! 4.) Janelle Monáe. I feel as if this young woman would be the life of the party! And certainly, the one to bring entertainment through performing for everyone and making sure everyone has fun. 5.) Dorothy
Read more

Paraphrase Practice

"Lincoln believed slavery was immoral, but he also considered the 13th Amendment a masterstroke in cutting away the financial foundations of the Confederacy.  I've rarely been more aware than during Steven Spielberg's "Lincoln" that Abraham Lincoln was a plain-spoken, practical, down-to-earth man from the farmlands of Kentucky, Indiana, and Illinois. He had less than a year of formal education and taught himself through his hungry reading of great books." -Roger Ebert's Lincoln Movie Review Lincoln was supporting and thought of the idea of slavery being an overall wrong, or inhumane, way through the ideas of personal standards in a consciousness of a human. He thought the 13th Amendment to be a brilliant way of chipping at the economic or money base ground point of the Confederacy. Like many Steven Spielberg very conscious in seeing how simple, blunt, realistic, and focused male of the countryside of Kentucky, Indian, and Illinois. This ma
Read more